Genii Weblog
More scam books to avoid
Mon 13 Dec 2010, 03:17 PM
Tweetby Ben Langhinrichs
Copyright © 2010 Genii Software Ltd.
What has been said:
929.1. Tim Paque (12/13/2010 08:31 PM)
I would definitely recommend complaining to Amazon or Barnes & Noble.
929.2. Bob Balfe (12/13/2010 08:58 PM)
It looks like a few of them already have terrible reviews on Amazon at least. One guys responded to the 4chan review with this:
"We believe that the quality of the Wikipedia-articles is so good that it is
worthwhile creating books with them. Wikipedia themselves give an impulse
for this. The articles published on their sites are free in every respect
and without any limitations as to further use.
Alphascript publishing is internet in form of a book. There can hardly be a
faster process. "
Which is not even the point! If I am going to buy a book, it better be much better than what I can get for free online.
929.3. Rob Weir (12/13/2010 09:01 PM)
They are prolific authors. For example, Agnes F. Vandome is listed on Amazon as authoring 98,780 titles.
But the largest is "Icon Group International" with over 400,000 titles.
These are all print-on-demand outfits, generating content either from databases or repackaging material from Wikipedia. I recall even seeing a patent on these techniques.
929.4. Ben Langhinrichs (12/13/2010 09:24 PM)
I have posted complaints at both BN.com and Amazon.com, but if anybody who has actually gotten stung could complain, it might have more impact.
(Or perhaps this is all so legal as to be unstoppable.)
929.5. Ulrich Krause (14.12.2010 05:00)
Could you post a template for the complaint, pls?
Although I guess they do not give a shit if you have not bought any of these books.
929.6. axel (14.12.2010 05:01)
LOL
Mankind will never be short of even the most feckless ideas to make some bucks.
Anybody should inform himself enough before buying a book.
929.7. Ian Scott (14/12/2010 13:25)
@Ben - I will follow up with Amazon.
It is actually not true to say that the 'XPages' book contains only one page on XPages. It is more accurate to say that what there is on XPages is printed on a single page - about 75%-80% of the page contains text with the remainder being white space.
In obtaining a refund from Amazon I had to explain why I wanted a refund and in doing so I made a particular point of the fact that when the book purports to be about XPages yet contains less than one page on the subject it is nothing but a con.
@Axel - I probably should have informed myself better but there really was no way to do so. It was a leap of faith. I would say that rather than being a poor book - and I would have tolerated it had it been a poor book - the book is in fact a deceit and that consumers are entitled to expect protection from this and especially when purchased through reputable resellers.
When I think about it now, UK Trading Standards might be interested in this book.